posted by
swmbo at 10:31am on 12/03/2009
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
The tail end of last Friday, a link on my flist led me to the incredibly detailed lists of posts collected by http://rydra-wong.livejournal.com/
It's been almost a week, and I've barely touched the surface of it, despite having spent hours and reading dozens and dozens of posts and hundreds if not thousand of comments. But I've read enough to become really, really angry. I've read enough to wake up dreaming about it last night and wake up upset and unable to think of anything else.
I'm pretty sure I'm preaching to the choir here - god I hope I am, and thank god I am - but - this is just NOT ok.
Some of the issues I've been aware of and bothered by for years - the depiction and lack of PoC in visual media. And yet even with that, I fail and miss things and only realize it after the fact that with all my pointing out the sexist issues with Castle, I failed to mention that almost every person at the book release party was a young, glamorous/wealthy, pretty *white* person.
Other issues are - awfully - new to me, and I hadn't realized just how bad the exclusion is in the written medium, much less in fandom itself. I have been graceless and clueless in the past, and I'll probably be so again in the future. I will continue to try to work on that.
I read Scalzi's post and the *godawful* comments that just continue to pile up on it, and I feel frustrated and sick and ashamed of a genre that I love that that many people - both professionals in the industry and their fans - continue to make excuses, continue to mischaracterize the situation, continue to dismiss something that has been spelled out for them line by line. And that they're being so self-congratulatory on how calm and rational they are in doing so.
So I just wanted to say that I do not dismiss problematic portrayal or lack of characters of color in SF/F, in the exclusion of PoC in either a fannish or author role. I do not dismiss it, I see it, I know that it is real and that it's a problem and that it's wrong.
I am still feeling out what I can do. But I can say - I am going to actively seek out more SF/F books by PoC, and that I have already started. And I will continue to listen, to seek out information and perspectives, to try to learn and to ask hard questions of myself.
(I'm reluctant to hit the post button on this right now, because I feel like there are far, far too many *I* statements in this, but it's the only framework I can work in at all right now. I originally disabled comments because of that, but that makes me feel even weirder and also I am not explaining that right so I stop now.)
It's been almost a week, and I've barely touched the surface of it, despite having spent hours and reading dozens and dozens of posts and hundreds if not thousand of comments. But I've read enough to become really, really angry. I've read enough to wake up dreaming about it last night and wake up upset and unable to think of anything else.
I'm pretty sure I'm preaching to the choir here - god I hope I am, and thank god I am - but - this is just NOT ok.
Some of the issues I've been aware of and bothered by for years - the depiction and lack of PoC in visual media. And yet even with that, I fail and miss things and only realize it after the fact that with all my pointing out the sexist issues with Castle, I failed to mention that almost every person at the book release party was a young, glamorous/wealthy, pretty *white* person.
Other issues are - awfully - new to me, and I hadn't realized just how bad the exclusion is in the written medium, much less in fandom itself. I have been graceless and clueless in the past, and I'll probably be so again in the future. I will continue to try to work on that.
I read Scalzi's post and the *godawful* comments that just continue to pile up on it, and I feel frustrated and sick and ashamed of a genre that I love that that many people - both professionals in the industry and their fans - continue to make excuses, continue to mischaracterize the situation, continue to dismiss something that has been spelled out for them line by line. And that they're being so self-congratulatory on how calm and rational they are in doing so.
So I just wanted to say that I do not dismiss problematic portrayal or lack of characters of color in SF/F, in the exclusion of PoC in either a fannish or author role. I do not dismiss it, I see it, I know that it is real and that it's a problem and that it's wrong.
I am still feeling out what I can do. But I can say - I am going to actively seek out more SF/F books by PoC, and that I have already started. And I will continue to listen, to seek out information and perspectives, to try to learn and to ask hard questions of myself.
(I'm reluctant to hit the post button on this right now, because I feel like there are far, far too many *I* statements in this, but it's the only framework I can work in at all right now. I originally disabled comments because of that, but that makes me feel even weirder and also I am not explaining that right so I stop now.)
There are 3 comments on this entry. (Reply.)